Saturday, April 26, 2014

Film Review: Ikiru (1952), directed by Akira Kurosawa

Ikiru is a satirical telling of a story of the post-diagnosis life of a bureaucrat with terminal stomach cancer.  A widower for over 20 years, the protagonist of the narrative, Watanabe Kanji, has been, as is narrated by voiceover, doing nothing for a least this long at his government office in which he spends the better chunk of his days.  Through the voiceover narrator, the director, Akira Kurosawa, explicitly asks viewers to think about “what life is all about”.  This becomes the conflict in Kanji’s tale, one he starts to wrestle with on the night of the day he finds out his fate, in the following scene.


Shot 1:  A still, medium, low-angle shot of Kanji from behind, climbing up the stairs that lead to his son Mitsuo's bedroom.  



Kanji paws for the last time at the thought of telling Mitsuo about the cancer that has shaken his life, before finally retreating back down the stairs.  In an earlier scene he waits up in Mitsuo's bedroom to tell him when he gets in, but he hears a conversation between Mitsuo and his wife upon their coming home that turns him off.  The Japanese maple leaf on the wallpaper in the bottom left corner of the shot is symbolism, possibly, for Kanji's peace with this decision to keep quiet.  The shot fades to black into:


Shot 2: A medium, low-angle shot of Kanji from behind in his bedroom; Kanji, in the center of the screen and in a bed robe, walks toward his closet doors.  To his right are the wooden paneled doors of his room.  To his left a light hangs from the ceiling.


The camera tilts down as Kanji walks, showing him straight on and slightly towards screen right.  Now visible, to the right and towards the foreground, is an alarm clock on a nightstand.  Kanji's bed mat and pillow are now visible to his left, under the hanging light.  Kanji hangs his shirt and coat among other garments on the outside of his closet.


Kanji turns and the camera starts to pan to the left, revealing more of his bed, and some belongings of his on the floor before the bed.


Kanji kneels over his bed in the center of the screen.





Slowly, he rolls his pants out, folded once and flat on his bed mat, rolls some bedding out over his pants, and places his pillow at the head of his bed.  He picks his pocket watch up off the floor and turns towards the camera.


The camera tilts up and pans to the right, following Kanji as he makes his way to his nightstand with his pocket watch in hand.


The camera tilts down at Kanji, who stares in melancholy thought as he slowly puts down his watch on the nightstand and picks up his alarm clock, which he starts to set.




Suddenly he throws the alarm clock to the floor and whimpers.  The camera follows him as he crawls into his bed and throws his whole body under covers.  Kurosawa cuts to:


Shot 3: A still, medium shot of the head of Kanji's bed.  His hand grasps the covers at his head and is all that can be seen of Kanji.  A cabinet that houses his late wife's photograph is in a niche in the background of the shot, to the right of a stack of books and below two certificates that hang above and outside the niche.  Kanji continues to whimper as the shot, through an axial cut, fades to:


Shot 4: A still, medium shot of the two certificates.  Kurosawa employs another axial cut to:


Shot 5:  A close up of the certificate on screen left, which reads, "Certificate of Appreciation in Recognition of 25 years of Distinguished Service".  Kanji's sobbing continues as the shot fades to black.

The shock and horror of Kanji's diagnosis sends him into a crisis he experiences in stages.  On the day that he learns of his fate, he comes down from the decision to kill himself, he psyches himself out of sharing his prognosis, and, in this scene, he decides he won't set his alarm to go to work the next day for the first time in almost thirty years.  Taking influence from silent film cinema, this scene is an artful expression of the absurdity of Kanji's tidy and regular life.  In fact, Kanji's life is so tidy and regular that he can't take it anymore.  As told by the narrator at the beginning of the film, Kanji has been as good as dead since he started working for the government.  Ironically, his death sentence brings him to life.

Ikiru isn't the only one of Kurosawa’s films that appears to be influenced by silent film.  In Roshomon (1950), Kurosawa simplifies the set and creates long scenes without nondiegetic sound, which give his work this quality.  Kuroswa also uses wipe transitions, which, too, are characteristic of silent cinema.

Some of Kurosawa's distinctive techniques, such as the axial cut used to zoom in on something, are present in Ikiru, but many of the techniques for which he goes on to be known, such as the use of a long lens camera and the use of multiple cameras at once, are not present in Ikiru.

A technique that seems to be unique to Ikiru is the use of music to explicitly reinforce what the film is about.  Kanji sings "Gondola no Uta" in full twice in this film.  "Life is brief", the song goes.  'Live before you can't any longer' is it's message.

Another characteristic of the director's films is the tendency of them not to obscure their substance and meaning.  The narrator at the beginning of Ikiru, Kampei at the end of Seven Samurai (1954), and Kikori at the end of Rashomon, all more or less state what the films they’re in are about.  What symbolism there is in Kurosawa’s work is simple to figure out or is outrightly explained.  Kanji, decided upon spending a chunk of his retirement, meets a novelist at a bar who takes him out into the city (Tokyo), where his hat gets stolen.  The writer suggests he buy a new one, telling him it will go with his “new self”, and telling Ikiru’s viewers that that is what the hat symbolizes.  The self that the writer has in mind though, one under his influence, is not the self that Kanji ultimately becomes.  After this night of indulgence, Kanji is swept up by the company of Toyo, a young coworker with a love of life and a ubiquitous laugh.  He becomes inspired by her to make something with the remaining time in his life.

Another thing Kurosawa’s films have in common are Kurosawa’s complex ideas about violence and destruction, and heroism.  The ronin in Seven Samurai are certainly heroes, but Kurosawa takes their conquest down a peg by bringing to light the fact that victory doesn’t necessarily belong to the victors, but to those with something worth defending.  In Rashomon he juxtaposes a slew of suspects of the rape of a woman and the murder of her husband with an individual who saves the life of an abandoned baby, to make the point that humanity isn’t good or bad and the decision to do good or bad comes from individuals.  In Ikiru, Kanji follows, instead of the destructive and indulgent path of the writer he meets, the heroic path to the aid of a construction project that turns a rotting cesspool into a playground.

A theme unique to Ikiru is the question of what inspires people to live and to be passionate about life.  Kanji dies in the playground he works to build.  At his funeral, after a night of drinking, the other government officials are able to see the value in the way Kanji lived the last few months of his life, but back at their offices, they continue to accomplish nothing.  According to Kurosawa, a death sentence isn’t the only catalyst for the kind of passion Kanji feels, because Toyo is passionate too.  So by not changing the hearts of the other bureaucrats with Kanji’s story, Kurosawa gets his audience that much more worked up.

Another theme Kurosawa presents that might be distinctive of Ikiru is anti-government.  What is implicit in Kurosawa’s criticism of the uninspired life of bureaucrats, who keep their positions by being as neutral as possible, and by doing as little as possible, is a criticism of bureaucracy itself.




 

Sunday, March 23, 2014

Scene Analysis Assignment: The Burmese Harp



The scene starts at 1:47:15.



Shot 1: A still, angled, birds’ eye view, long shot of the soldiers on their ship; foremost in the shot are parts of the ship’s rig (beams and/or masts).  One man walks across the crowded floor from screen right towards screen left.  The others mostly sit in circles cross-legged.  Some, on the right of the screen, are standing in a corner of the ship looking out at the water.  A nondigetic, slow, low pitched, orchestral instrument is present over ambient ocean sounds.  In this shot the mise-en-scene sets up the setting and the music sets up the mood.



Shot 2: A tracking long shot away from the land the soldiers are leaving; near the shore are a handful of sailboats and paddleboats.  The sky is filled with clouds and takes up more room in the frame than the sea.  A white pagoda sticks out along the shoreline about a third of the way in the frame from the left.


Shot 3: A still, medium shot of the men looking out over the side of the ship.  More men stand then before.  Four men fill the frame, directly standing behind the ship’s rail, facing out.  Captain Inouye stands at screen left with his elbows resting on the rail and his arms both touched by the opposite hand, but not crossed.  The soldier next to him rests his arm on the rail, has his head down, and he looks into his open left hand, possibly at Mizushima's ruby.  The arm of the man to the his left is around his shoulder.  This man stands straight up.  The next soldier to the right has his elbows on the rail and his left arms hangs out over it.  The right of the frame cuts off a fifth man, also leaning on the rail.  Wind blows through the soldiers’ hats.


Shot 4: Another tracking shot of the shore; there is a different mise-en-scene from before and more sea is in the frame than sky.


Shot 5:  An extreme close up of the fourth soldier’s face as he looks out.


Shot 6: A shot just like shot 2 only there are just two sailboats visible and the pagoda is more prominent; the pagoda is now placed a third of the screen in from the right.  By the end of the shot only one sailboat remains in the picture as the camera moves to the right and the sailboats move toward screen left.  This pagoda represents Mizushima and his duty on the land the others abandon.


Shot 7: A still, medium shot of soldiers crowded on the ship; those in the foreground lie down.  Some soldiers in the middle ground sit up and laugh.  One is rifling through a bag and another has a bottle-probably sake.  Some stand in the background.  The music no longer plays.  Not much is happening in shots 2 through 7 and we are compelled to reflect as the soldier's do deeply, looking back at the land they leave.  They must come to terms with their decision to surrender, the loss of Mizushima conflicting with their pride in him, and the fact that they escape death while in a way, Mizushima doesn't.


Shot 8: A still shot of the captain opening the letter from Mizushima; the captain is standing in the background of the frame, about a third in from screen left, facing the camera.  He looks around at the soldiers as he speaks.  In the foreground are the four soldiers who were with the captain at the rail, facing one another and not facing Mizushima.  A structure separates these soldiers from soldiers in the middle ground who face Captain Inouye, also seated.  The water and sky are visible in the top right corner of the frame over the ship’s railing.


Shot 9:  A nearer shot to the captain; this time the foreground consists of the backs of two soldiers’ heads who are facing the captain.  Captain Inouye is placed more left in the frame than in the last shot, and the water and sky take up about a fourth of the frame.  He continues to tear open Mizushima’s letter.  The subtitles read, “I think I understand how he feels.  When I went to the repository that day and saw that white box, I understood.  But I felt uneasy and said nothing about it.  I think this letter will answer your questions.”  The ruby inside the funeral box symbolizes the core elements of Buddhism.  The captain picks up on what this means but hopes the letter will be able to explain Mizushima's reasoning.


Shot 10: A still close up of the captain from the waist up; he is centered in the frame and the pages of the letter are now in his hands.  He holds the letter at his chest and starts to read it.  “My captain and my brothers at arms…” he says before pausing and looking about, “it’s difficult to express how much I miss you all, how much I want to join you, work with you, talk with you and sing with you.  It’s even harder to express how I long to return to my war-ravaged country and see the ones I love.”  Another pause before the shot is cut to:


Shot 11:  A medium shot of the soldiers filling the frame, looking attentively towards the captain and to the camera’s right.  Cutting to the soldier's faces after hearing such words successfully conveys the soldier's anticipatory confusion and distress.  “But I cannot return”, Mizushima explains through the captain, “I cannot leave the bodies of my comrades lying scattered along the hills and rivers of Burma."


Shot 12: A medium shot of the back of the captain, silhouetted and to the screen right.  The soldiers fill two thirds of the screen to his left.  The parrot sits on a diagonally laid beam at screen left.  The parrot squawks in between Mizushima's words.  The parrot interrupts the captain and the men turn to it.  “No I can’t go back,” the bird reiterates for Mizushima. 


Shot 13:  A close up of the parrot on its perch; the soldiers who fill the foreground stare at it, shocked.  It makes a quieter sound and turns its head towards the listening soldiers.  The parrot not only restates Mizushima's words but brings back up front the soldiers' bafflement.


Shot 14:  This shot is back to the close-up of Inouye.  He pauses and his lightly shaking hands rustle the letter in them before the shot cuts to:


Shot 15: A shot tracking to the left; the ocean takes up the bottom two-thirds of the frame and the sky, the rest.  Inouye continues to read.  The music starts up again; this time a harp plays.  The bird's display and the soundtrack work well transitionally here, as the letter takes us from the what to the why.  “Why must the world suffer such misery?  Why must there be such inexplicable pain?  As the days passed, I came to understand.  I realized that, in the end, the answers were not for human beings to know, that our work is simply to ease the great suffering of the world.  To have the courage to face suffering, senselessness and irrationality without fear, to find the strength to create peace by one’s own example."


Shot 16: A medium shot of the captain and the backs of a handful of the soldiers’ heads.  The water and sky again take up space in the top right corner of the frame.  The captain takes the first page of the letter and places it behind the last and continues to read the letter.


Shot 17: An extreme close up of two of the soldiers’ faces, angled toward the out of frame captain and screen left.  Other faces fill the background of the frame.  “I will stay behind to create a place where those thousands of young souls can find repose."


Shot 18: An extreme close up of an out of focus, cut off soldiers’ face on screen left, a soldier to his right is slightly behind him and in focus.  This soldier has a tear streaming down his face.  He swallows as the captain goes on reading.  “After many years, when that task is done, I may return to Japan if possible.”



Shot 19:  An extreme close up of a soldier’s face angled down and to screen right.  Another soldier is out of focus in the background and to the screen right.  “But even then I may not.  My life may end here."


Shot 20:  A medium shot angled directly at the ships railing so that the sea and sky take up the length of the background.  The captain is on the screen left and the backs of a few soldiers with their heads down are in the middle ground as he keeps reading.


Shot 21:  Ichikawa brings us back to the angle behind the captain as the captain moves on to the next page.  “There is no end to words of farewell.  Those of you who still think of me, please accept my deepest thanks.  From snow-capped mountains to the coast where the Southern Cross shines, I shall wander throughout Burma.  Whenever my loneliness becomes unbearable, I’ll play my harp.”


Shot 22: Another medium shot of the captain standing in front of the soldiers and in the background of the frame.  “Thank you for everything you’ve done for me.  I shall always pray for your happiness.”  He moves the last page to the back and folds the pages together.  The letter is ultimately reassuring.



Shot 23: Another close up of the parrot on it’s perch.  The soldiers behind it in the frame have their heads down.  One has his hand over his eyes.  A shadow is cast over the parrot and it is silhouetted.  The shadow quickly retreats and Ichikawa cuts to:


Shot 24: A tracking shot of the sun setting over the water that is now black.  The clouds above the sun are dark and the sky below is light.  The camera sways up and down.  The music stops and the sound of waves crashing are present.  "The sun sets" on the soldiers and they will move on.